What Estate Sale Companies Don't Tell You (Until It's Too Late)
Estate sale companies vary enormously in quality, ethics, and results. Most families hire one under time pressure, without knowing what questions to ask, and without understanding that the contract they sign determines whether they come out ahead or get taken advantage of. Here is what the industry does not volunteer.
Quick answers
- Commission rates vary from 25% to 50% , the lowest rate is not always the best deal
- Most contracts give the company full control over pricing, including markdowns
- Unsold items are often donated or disposed of without your approval if not specified in the contract
- Some companies charge setup fees, cleanup fees, or advertising fees on top of commission
- Your presence during the sale is usually discouraged, which limits your oversight
The Commission Rate Is Only Part of the Story
A 30% commission sounds better than 40%. But commission rate alone tells you almost nothing about what you will actually net.
What matters more: the company's ability to price items accurately, their buyer network and marketing reach, how aggressively they discount on day two and day three, and what happens to items that do not sell. A company that charges 40% but prices well, draws large crowds, and sells 90% of the inventory will net you more than one that charges 25% and moves 50%.
When comparing companies, ask for references from families with similar estates. Ask what percentage of items typically sell. Ask what the average gross revenue has been for estates of similar size and type. The commission conversation should come after those questions, not before.
Things to Look for in the Contract
Pricing authority
Most contracts give the company full discretion over pricing. That means they decide what your parent's china is worth, and you have no recourse if you think it was priced too low. Some contracts allow the family to flag specific items for minimum pricing. Ask for this if there are items you believe have significant value.
Markdown policy
The standard practice is to discount everything on the final day of the sale, often by 25% to 50% or more. Some companies discount as early as the afternoon of day one. Ask specifically: when do markdowns begin, by how much, and who authorizes them. This is often where the most valuable items go for well below market.
What happens to unsold items
This is the clause most families do not read carefully. Contracts vary widely: some companies donate unsold items to charity, some charge a buyout fee for the company to take them, some leave everything in place and expect the family to handle it. A few donate items and receive a tax deduction they keep. Know exactly what happens to everything that does not sell before you sign.
Additional fees
Setup fees, cleanup fees, advertising fees, credit card processing fees, and hauling fees are all charged by some companies above and beyond the commission. Ask for a complete list of every fee that could appear on the settlement statement. The commission is the starting point, not the ceiling.
Settlement timeline
Most reputable companies settle within 5 to 14 days after the sale. Some contracts allow 30 days or more. Ask when you will receive payment and what documentation you will receive with it. A detailed settlement statement showing individual sales or at minimum total gross revenue is standard practice.
The Items They Quietly Keep
This is the area where some estate sale companies operate unethically, and where families who are not paying attention lose the most.
Cherry-picking before the sale opens. Some companies or their employees purchase desirable items at setup prices before the public can access them. This is a direct conflict of interest. Ask explicitly whether staff are permitted to purchase items, and if so, under what conditions.
Donated item tax deductions. When companies donate unsold items to charity and receive the tax deduction themselves, they are capturing a financial benefit that should arguably go to the estate. Some states prohibit this; others do not. Ask who receives the tax documentation for donated items.
Missing cash. In homes where cash is found during setup, the handling of that cash should be documented and reported to the family. Ask how the company handles cash found on the property during setup and during the sale.
Get an Appraisal Before You Call Anyone
Before contacting estate sale companies, have a certified appraiser walk through the home and identify items with significant value. This takes two to four hours and costs $200 to $400. It gives you a baseline so you can evaluate whether a company's pricing aligns with actual market value, and it protects you from not knowing that the antique bureau in the bedroom is worth $3,000.
Questions to Ask Every Company You Interview
Interview at least three companies before choosing. Ask each one:
- What is your commission rate, and what fees are charged in addition to commission?
- How do you determine pricing, and can we flag items for minimum prices?
- When and by how much do you discount on the final day?
- What happens to items that do not sell?
- Can your staff purchase items, and if so, how is that handled?
- Who receives the tax deduction for donated items?
- How do you handle cash found on the property?
- When do you settle and what does the settlement statement include?
- Can you provide three references from families with estates similar to ours?
A reputable company will answer every one of these questions without hesitation. Vague answers or resistance to specific questions are a signal.
Red Flags Worth Walking Away From
No written contract. Any company that operates without a detailed written contract is not worth hiring.
Pressure to sign quickly. Urgency is a sales tactic. Reputable companies understand that families need time to review contracts.
No references or only testimonials on their own website. Ask for names and contact information of families they have worked with in the last year.
Commission so low it seems implausible. A company charging 15% commission is either subsidizing through fees you have not seen yet, or they are cutting corners on marketing and staffing that will reduce your net.
Unwillingness to allow a family member to observe the sale. You may not want to be present, but you should have the right to be.
What Reputable Companies Do Well
Good estate sale companies earn their commission. They photograph and research items before pricing, bring a buyer network that includes dealers and collectors, stage the home so items are accessible and appealing, manage the sale day logistics including crowd control and security, and provide a clean settlement statement.
The best companies treat the estate respectfully, price items at or near market value rather than clearance value, and communicate proactively with families throughout the process. They exist. Finding them requires asking the right questions.
Step 1 of 2
How big is the home?
Step 2 of 2
What kind of help is needed?
Estimated Cost
Last step
Where should we look for certified SMMs?
No spam. No sales calls unless you want them. We’ll match you with NASMM-certified professionals near you.
You’re all set!
Thanks, use the cost range above as a starting point when you contact Senior Move Managers near you.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do estate sale companies charge?
Commission rates typically range from 25% to 50% of gross sales. The most common range for a standard residential estate is 30% to 40%. Commission is only part of the cost: some companies add setup fees, advertising fees, cleanup fees, or credit card processing fees. Always ask for a complete list of fees before signing.
Can you negotiate with an estate sale company?
Yes. Commission rates, minimum pricing for specific items, markdown policies, and what happens to unsold items are all negotiable. Companies with strong track records and busy schedules have less incentive to negotiate; companies that are newer or less in demand have more. The contract is the negotiation, and everything in it is worth discussing before you sign.
What happens to items that don't sell at an estate sale?
It depends entirely on the contract. Common arrangements include: the family retains unsold items and handles disposition themselves; the company donates items to charity; the company offers a buyout option to take remaining items for a flat fee; or the company hauls items away and charges a disposal fee. Know exactly which arrangement applies before the sale starts. Do not assume.
Should you be present at an estate sale?
Most companies discourage family presence during the sale because it can be emotionally difficult and can complicate the sales process when family members override pricing or engage with buyers about specific items. That said, you have the right to observe. If you want to be present, establish that in writing before signing. A company that refuses to allow any family presence is worth scrutinizing.
Sources
What is a Senior Move Manager? A Senior Move Manager is a trained specialist who helps older adults and their families navigate moves, downsizing, and care transitions. They handle the logistics so you don't have to.
An SMM coordinates the full downsizing process from sorting and estate sales to donating and disposing so your family does not have to manage every detail.
✓ 528 NASMM-certified professionals · ✓ All 50 states